Sign in
  • Home
  • News
    • Defence
    • Foreign
    • Pictures
    • Africa
  • Politics
  • Business
    • Aviation
    • Capital Market
    • Coronavirus
    • Energy
    • Finance and Banking
    • Industry
    • Insurance
    • IT & Tel
    • Property
    • Transport
    • Aviation
    • Industry
    • Energy
  • Sports
    • Ronaldo
  • Entertainment
    • Scoop
  • Features
    • Special Contribution
    • Art
    • Tourism
    • Opinion
Sign in
Welcome!Log into your account
Forgot your password?
Password recovery
Recover your password
Search
2.8 C
New York
Thursday, January 14, 2021
  • Sign in / Join
  • Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Infotrust News
  • Home
  • News
    • AllDefenceForeignPictures
      A ballot box during a past election at the Nasuti polling station in Mukono District, Uganda, (AFP)
      Africa

      Uganda Orders Internet Shutdown Hours Before Election

      Headlines

      Islamic Group Attacks Amotekun, Makes Accusations

      Crime

      Court Sentences Student To 14 Months Imprisonment For Theft, Possession Of…

      Headlines

      COVID-19: 20 Doctors Test Positive In Kwara

    • Africa
  • Politics
    • APC

      Just In: Akeredolu Wins Again

      Headlines

      Ekiti Guber: ‘Segun Oni Is The Only One Who Can Give…

      News

      Under Heavy Guard, Congress Back To Work After Trump Supporters Storm…

      Headlines

      Pro-Trump Protesters Storm U.S. Capitol As Lawmakers Debate Election Results

      Headlines

      I Will Never Concede, Trump Tells Supporters

  • Business
    • AllAviationCapital MarketCoronavirusEnergyFinance and BankingIndustryInsuranceIT & TelPropertyTransport
      Coronavirus

      COVID-19: Nigeria Records 1,398 New Infections, Active Cases Now 20,062

      Africa

      No Coronavirus Vaccine Approved In Ghana – FDA

      Coronavirus

      COVID-19: NANS Warns ASUU Against Stopping Resumption Of Universities

      Business

      Stanbic IBTC Supports Businesses with Bouquet of Solutions

    • Aviation
    • Industry
    • Energy
  • Sports
    • AllRonaldo
      Sports

      Neymar Returns To PSG Training Ahead Of Champions Trophy

      Football

      Enugu Govt Celebrates Christian Chukwu At 70

      Football

      Ronaldo Overtakes Pele As the Second-Highest Goalscorer Of ALL-TIME

      Headlines

      Transfer: Messi free to speak with EPL clubs

  • Entertainment
    • AllScoop
      Entertainment

      ‘Oloture’ – Mo Abudu Reacts To Tobore Allegations, Makes Revelations

      Entertainment

      Veteran Actress, Orisabunmi Is Dead

      Entertainment

      Theatre Arts Practitioners Mourn Nollywood Actress Orisabunmi

      Entertainment

      DJ Cuppy Shares Growth Of Her Pet Lion In Dubai

  • Features
    • AllSpecial Contribution
      Africa

      Will Stolen African Artefacts Ever Find Their Way Back Home?

      Africa

      Key Things To Know About Uganda, The ‘Pearl Of Africa’

      Features

      Real Reasons Atiku Sold Intels’ Stake

      Business

      8 Ways To Avoid Cashflow Problems In Your Business

    • Art
      • Art

        New Afrika Shrine Karnival To Hold On Jan 17th & 18th

        Art

        Trump’s Reaction To A Nigerian Artist Painting

        Art

        A Peek Into The World Of Afro-beat: Edaoto

        Africa

        Belgian Festival Draws Criticism Over Blackface ‘Savage’ Character

        Art

        Ekiti Gov., Kayode Fayemi Kicks-Off Festivals Of Arts And Culture

    • Tourism
      • Africa

        Will Stolen African Artefacts Ever Find Their Way Back Home?

        Tourism

        27 Things You Should Know Ahead Of Your Summer Road Trip

        Business

        Pekamol Unveils Newly Built Hospitality Subsidiary

        Headlines

        French Tourism Loses $70bn Due To COVID-19 Restrictions – Official

        Headlines

        Oniru Woos Hilton Hotel Group to Victoria Island

    • Opinion
      • Opinion

        Despite Hefty Debt Why Go For Unclaimed And Dormant Accounts?

        Justice Walter Samuel Nkanu Onnoghen
        Headlines

        When Justice Flees The Judiciary, The Country Dies A Little.

        Opinion

        Bakare Didn’t Defend Tinubu; He Defanged Him

        Professor Biodun Jeyifo
        Opinion

        Study Notes On ‘State’ And ‘State Failure’

        Opinion

        Rescued Or Released: Who Should We Believe On Return Of Kankara…

Home Africa Will Stolen African Artefacts Ever Find Their Way Back Home?
  • Africa
  • Features
  • Headlines
  • Tourism

Will Stolen African Artefacts Ever Find Their Way Back Home?

By
Fred Oluoch
-
January 14, 2021
Share on Facebook
Tweet on Twitter
  • It is estimated that between 80 and 90 per cent of sub-Saharan Africa’s ancient cultural heritage is held outside the continent as a result of conquest, plunder, theft, and colonisation, as well as legitimate trade and exchange.

Heritage activist Mwazulu Diyabanza, from Congo, has been on a grabbing spree of African artefacts in European museums that were stolen from former colonies. His actions have left him with a total bill of $9,771 in fines.

What is driving Diyabanza to take ethnographic collections that are on display in museums across Europe? It’s his frustration with stringent ancient laws that go back to the 16th century in most European countries that consider cultural heritage materials stolen from Africa as “inalienable”.

Diyabanza, 41, has always defended himself on the basis that his actions cannot be considered theft because the objects were already stolen property.

He was first fined $6,107 for removing an object from a display case at the Louvre Museum in Paris. He had earlier been fined $1,221 for similar activities at Quai Branly Museum in Marseille, and $2,442 for removing display items at the Musée du quai Branly-Jacques Chirac Museum.

But Diyabanza — who is representative of millions of Africans who are seeking restitution of cultural artefacts stolen decades ago — may rest easy following an initiative by French President Emmanuel Macron.

After over a century of resistance by European museums to initiate restitution of African heritage materials stolen during the colonial rule, France has taken the initiative to engage the continent on modalities of returning thousands of these objects that are of great artistic, cultural, religious, sacred and economic value.

When President Macron came to power in May 2017, he toured a number of African countries and promised to initiate the repatriation of African cultural heritage items unjustly held “prisoner” by French museums: France holds more than 90,000 items.

He went on to commission a study undertaken by academics Felwine Sarr and Bénédicte Savoy whose report, The Restitution of African Cultural Heritage. Towards a New Relational Ethics, recommends unconditional repatriation of African cultural materials.

In November, the French parliament approved a Bill for the full return of 26 objects from Musée du quai Branly in Paris, to Benin, as well as other items to Senegal that were already on loan from the French Army Museum, to the Museum of Black Civilisations that opened in December 2018 in Dakar. There is hope that ownership of these objects will be officially transferred before the end of this year.

Setback

But on December 8, 2020, the French repatriation process suffered a setback when it watered down the repatriation law, adopting a case-by-case approach. Thus far, that would mean separate requests for around 13,000 objects originating from Ethiopia, Chad, Côte d’Ivoire, Mali, and Madagascar.

The biggest challenge now is that none of the 55 African counties have enacted laws to officially demand for restitution of the hundreds of thousands of cultural artefacts that were looted from Africa during the colonial period and are major tourism attractions at European museums.

The new Berlin Castle (Humboldt Forum) is seen in Berlin on December 23, 2020. – The Prussian palace opened in Berlin on December 16, 2020 as a museum complex housing colonial artifacts, just as debate is gathering pace around the return of treasures plundered from abroad. (Photo by STEFANIE LOOS / AFP)

George Abungu, an international heritage consultant and a former director-general of the National Museums of Kenya (NMK), says that during the negotiations for independence, most African countries had asked for the return of looted cultural items.

It is estimated that between 80 and 90 percent of sub-Saharan Africa’s ancient cultural heritage is currently held outside the continent as a result of conquest, plunder, theft, and colonisation, as well as legitimate trade and exchange.

Juma Ondeng, the NMK curator at Kitale Museum, who has been leading the International Inventories Programme (IIP), said that the challenge is that most African countries, Kenya included, do not have rules and regulations on repatriation.

“Given the lack of policy and laws, you find a situation where individual communities are petitioning the British government directly for the return of their artefacts. Cases where there has been success are when the government intervenes and negotiates on behalf of the communities, such as the one going on between Nigeria and Britain over the Benin Bronzes,” said Ondeng.

The Benin Bronzes, which are actually made of brass, are a collection of delicately made sculptures and plaques that adorned the royal palace of the Oba, Ovonramwen Nogbaisi, in the Kingdom of Benin, which was incorporated into British-ruled Nigeria.

In Kenya, the Pokomo community from the Coast has petitioned the British government for the return of the unique Pokomo drum known as ngach, which was stolen by British soldiers during the Second World War.

The Bukusu community from Bungoma County in western Kenya have also petitioned for the return of their cultural materials that were looted by British soldiers in 1895 during the Lumboka expedition.

Ondeng says that the IIP — funded by the Goethe Institute and working with Pitt Rivers Museum in the UK and other partners in Germany and France — has so far collected data of 32,501 objects of Kenyan origin held by 30 institutions in seven countries,

He says the next step is the Provenance Research to establish how the objects left Kenya and their current locations. “We are hoping that the data will help NMK and the government come up with policies and laws that will help in the negotiations for repatriation.”

Obstacles

Ondeng says that the biggest obstacles to repatriation are that European countries consider these items national assets with value attached to them and that museums use them as collateral to secure funds for their operations.

He said that items held in national museums in Europe are subject to parliamentary approval, while those held by private museums are flexible such as the Pitt Rivers Museum that is currently revisiting its repatriation policy.

The other challenge is that some European museums in attempt to tone down the growing agitation for repatriation have resorted to long term loans of these items to African countries, but which in essence they are legally bound to only display them and keep them safe and cannot claim ownership.

Purity Kiura, the director of Antiquities, Sites and Monuments at NMK, said most museums abroad have been advocating for the loaning of the artefacts because they hold international collections and it would be a blow for them to repatriate most of the objects.

“Many individual collectors have been donating or handing over their collections to museums. They know there are no laws that can force museums to return collections, and most of them have given conditions such as asking museums to make sure these collections go into permanent exhibitions,” said Kiura.

In 2005, Ethiopia negotiated for the return of its 1,700-year-old Obelisk, a religious granite post that was returned after 68 years in Italy. It was looted by the troops of the Italian dictator Benito Mussolini.

From East Africa, the British are holding hundreds of historical and cultural items such as the Baganda Royal Drums, and the cloaks worn by Marakwet paramount chief Chemtut when he visited London in 1960s on the invitation of English Queen Elizabeth II.

Also on show are instruments of leadership and major political events in post-colonial East Africa like a khanga commemorating the 1967 Arusha Declaration — when Tanzania established Ujamaa.

The Luo traditional Ogut Tigo (beaded cap) worn by Kenyan politicians Jomo Kenyatta, Oginga Odinga, Tom Mboya and Ronald Ngala during the Independence constitutional negotiations at Lancaster, as a symbol of nationalism, is also in their museums.

The stuffed bodies of the two man-eaters of Tsavo are on display at the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago. These were two infamous lions from Tsavo in Kenya that killed several railway workers on the British Kenya-Uganda track at the end of the 19th century.

  • TAGS
  • AFP
  • Benin
  • Chad
  • Congo
  • Emmanuel Macron
  • Ethiopia
  • France
  • Germany
  • II
  • IIP
  • International Inventories Programme (IIP)
  • italy
  • kenya
  • LOOS
  • Madagascar
  • Mali
  • National Museums of Kenya (NMK)
  • Niger
  • NMK
  • Rivers
  • Senegal
  • STEFANIE
  • Tanzania
  • uganda
  • UK
SHARE
Facebook
Twitter
Previous articleKey Things To Know About Uganda, The ‘Pearl Of Africa’
Fred Oluoch

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Africa

Key Things To Know About Uganda, The ‘Pearl Of Africa’

Medical personnel check temperatures of patients visiting Mpilo Hospital in Bulawayo, Zimbabwe, on April 25, 2020. PHOTO | ZINYANGE AUNTONY | AFP
Africa

Virus Infections Sinking Zimbabwe Onto Its Knees

A ballot box during a past election at the Nasuti polling station in Mukono District, Uganda, (AFP)
Africa

Uganda Orders Internet Shutdown Hours Before Election

Headlines

Islamic Group Attacks Amotekun, Makes Accusations

Crime

Court Sentences Student To 14 Months Imprisonment For Theft, Possession Of Weapon

Headlines

COVID-19: 20 Doctors Test Positive In Kwara

Coronavirus

COVID-19: Nigeria Records 1,398 New Infections, Active Cases Now 20,062

Foreign

No Senate Impeachment Trial For Trump, Says Majority Leader

Headlines

Trump Ban Was Right But Sets Dangerous Precedent – Twitter Chief

MOST POPULAR

ONDO ASSEMBLY REINSTATES IMPEACHED DEPUTY SPEAKER,IROJU OGUNDEJI

May 24, 2018

Ronaldo looms for Morocco as Russia basks in glory

June 20, 2018

Halima Abubakar Buys New Whip, Escalade EXT

October 29, 2019

EFCC arrests fake pastor over N1.33 Billion scam

June 1, 2018
Load more

EDITOR PICKS

Will Stolen African Artefacts Ever Find Their Way Back Home?

January 14, 2021

Key Things To Know About Uganda, The ‘Pearl Of Africa’

January 14, 2021
Medical personnel check temperatures of patients visiting Mpilo Hospital in Bulawayo, Zimbabwe, on April 25, 2020. PHOTO | ZINYANGE AUNTONY | AFP

Virus Infections Sinking Zimbabwe Onto Its Knees

January 14, 2021

POPULAR POSTS

Prof Salako replaces embattled Ujah, as workers jubilate over sack of...

July 31, 2016

UK Minister for Africa Harriett Baldwin visits Zimbabwe

February 1, 2018

Egypt’s non-oil business sector activity stabilises in Jan – PMI

February 5, 2018

POPULAR CATEGORY

  • News24898
  • Headlines15047
  • Sports10183
  • Politics3783
  • Africa2440
  • Business2230
  • Entertainment1892
  • Crime1833
  • Features879
ABOUT US
InfoTrust Multimedia Limited Ikeja, Lagos.
Contact us: [email protected]
FOLLOW US
  • Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
© 2019 Infotrustng.com. All Righs Reserved.
Edit with Live CSS
Save
Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete.